Saturday, May 20, 2006
Loose Change
Saturday, May 13, 2006
Revolt stirs as Dubai aims high
A saying by Imam Ali...
Iraqi marriages defy civil war spectre
I truly love this....
Father Frank's Rant
Rant Number 209 21 March 2006
BehemothFrom the killing fields of Iraq, a troubled British soldier asks the priest:“…what should we do? Quitting? We just had our Defence Minister here…said itwould be a crime to cut and run…leave the Iraqis in the lurch…wrong of us…wediscuss this every day…but no longer believe in it…what do you advise,Padre?”Tough one, Clive. (Not his real name.) A bit of a bugger. Best to have achat with your Army chaplain. But damned right you are to be perplexed. Itisn’t that there aren’t arguments pro and con. That’s normal. But what ifthe moral situation is so diabolical that the West, or what passes for it,whatever it does, it does wrong? We stay in – mayhem goes on, terrorismthrives, Shia and Sunnis slaughter each other, all Iraqis hate us. We getout – Iraq explodes into all-out civil war, the country breaks up, Zarqawitriumphs, etcetera.For a person of a faith, this dilemma seems horrific. Demonic. Tantamount tosaying that a thoughtful believer, a man with a conscience, would have noalternative, no choice, whatever he does, but to sin. Indeed, he’d be forcedto. Damned if you do, damned if you don’t. OK for Realpolitikers, perhaps,but certainly not for a Christian. Because it would mean he is trapped in amalevolent cosmos in which not God but Behemoth is in charge.Don’t groan. I shall clarify. It goes back to Pope St Gregory the Great. Hiscomment on an obscure verse in that delightfully proto-absurdist text, theBook of Job. Of formidable, hippopotamus-like Behemoth, held to symboliseSatan, Job informs us “the sinews of his thighs are knit together”. (40:17)Enlightening, eh? Mercifully St Gregory, a sharp moral theologian, rides tothe rescue. Here is his ingenious exegesis: “The sinews of Satan’s testiclesare wrapped closely together. Meaning the suggestions that he whispers tomen are bound together by crafty tricks. Designed to make us sin. In thisway: though we try to escape sinning one sin, we find we can avoid that onlyby committing another one.”A load of old cobblers, as a sceptical Cockney might quip? Not quite. Satanis of course a spirit. Hence any physical description can only bemetaphorical. St Gregory brings that out. From the devil’s nature – he is aliar and the father of lies – issue his innumerable ruses and twists, aimedat making men stumble. A murderer from the beginning, little wonder he isintent in fomenting strife and wars of all kinds. And his devices can bepretty lethal. Like the four hoodlums convicted in Reading yesterday fortorturing and murdering a girl. As the brutes were at it, one of themconfessed at the trial, “I felt as if somebody else was present in the room:the devil”. It chilled my blood to hear that.Satan’s power, however, is limited. Because he is only a creature.Infinitely inferior to the Creator. (Behemoth, huge and menacing as he is,is still part of God’s design, submitted to Him.) Although the fiend cantempt us, he cannot make us sin. Nor should we fall back on the Evil One toexculpate ourselves from the moral consequences of our free actions. Indeed,it’s best to be wary of exaggerating his influence. “Fr Frank, do youbelieve in the power of evil?” A lady obsessed with exorcisms and possessiononce asked me. “Madam, indeed I do” I replied, “but much more I believe inthe power of good!” Sigh.. I suspect she went on believing the devil is akind of god.Behemoth’s balls apart, do these dilemmas have an acceptable solution? Well,kind of. You see, St Thomas Aquinas holds there is a type of moralperplexity that necessarily entails bad outcomes for an agent but does notthereby threaten our sense of being in a moral universe. In such cases,indeed, whatever a man does, inevitably he sins, given an initial fault forwhich he is responsible. Imagine I have promised my friend Brian to take hischildren to Regent’s Park zoo, while at the same time promising Teresa,another friend, that I would take her children out, on the same day and atthe same time. Whatever he does, thoughtless Fr Frank will sin, i.e. break apromise and cause disappointment and sorrow to some child. No way out. Butwhy? Plainly, because of prior wrongdoing on his part. So, alas, I can onlyescape from the dilemma by doing wrong to someone. But, there is nothingintrinsically diabolical here. No contradiction, no denial of divineProvidence. Only my moral wilfulness, weakness, stupidity or what you will.Logically, by ensnaring myself in such a tangle, by doing something I shouldnot have done in the first place, I have brought it about that I cannot butdo wrong, whatever I do. Bad, yes. Demonic? Hardly.Only a nagging doubt. In moral casuistry, a lot hinges on the examples.Failing to take children to the zoo is one thing. Guess someone who has soldhis soul to the devil, like Faust, would feel a little more about worked upabout his plight. (Remember: Faust had given his word. Of course, he was aGerman. A Latin might have had fewer qualms – I say – fiendishly?) WishAquinas had discussed a case like that…Finally, Iraq. In Just War theory terms, it appears almost impossible not toregard the 2003 invasion as a peccatum – a sin. Because it was an aggressiveact of war, unjustified, unnecessary and illegal. Given that initial, fatalstep, with all the destruction, bloodshed and crimes that ensued,necessarily the West, whatever it does or will do, it will be morally wrong.Some grave injustice will follow. And, please, don’t come up with the old,convenient ‘lesser evil’ line. A lesser evil is still an evil. Especiallywhen there was nothing inevitable about it in the first place.So, Clive. As a volunteer, professional soldier in a non-conscript Army,taking the Queen’s money, his scope for conscientious objection, I wouldhave thought, is rather limited. His scruples, however, do him credit. GoodBritish lad. Buon sangue non mente!Revd Frank Julian Gelli
48-Hour Internet Outage Plunges Nation Into Productivity
Fuck Everything, We're Doing Five Blades
Porn cocktail leaves a bitter taste
Why Iraq's Police Are a Menace
Critics say Interior Minister has turned the U.S.-trained force into Shi'ite shock troops
By CHRISTOPHER ALLBRITTON/BAGHDAD
The bodies began to show up early last week. On Monday, 34 corpses were found. In the darkness of Tuesday morning, 15 more men, between the ages of 22 and 40 were found in the back of a pickup truck in the al-Khadra district of western Baghdad. They had been hanged. By daybreak, 40 more bodies were found around the city, most bearing signs of torture before the men were killed execution-style. The most gruesome discovery was an 18-by-24-foot mass grave in the Shi'ite slum of Kamaliyah in east Baghdad containing the bodies of 29 men, clad only in their underwear with their hands bound and their mouths covered with tape. Local residents only found it because the ground was oozing blood. In all, 87 bodies were found over two days in Baghdad.
The grisly discovery was horrible enough, the latest and perhaps most chilling sign that Iraq is descending further into butchery — and quite possibly civil war. But almost as disturbing is the growing evidence that the massacres and others like it are being tolerated and even abetted by Iraq's Shi'ite-dominated police forces, overseen by Iraq's Interior Minister, Bayan Jabr. On his watch, sectarian militias have swelled the ranks of the police units and, Sunnis charge, used their positions to carry out revenge killings against Sunnis. While allowing an Iranian-trained militia to take over the ministry, critics say, Jabr has authorized the targeted assassination of Sunni men and stymied investigations into Interior-run death squads. Despite numerous attempts to contact them, neither Jabr nor Interior Ministry spokesmen responded to requests for comment on this article.
Jabr's and his forces' growing reputation for brutality comes at a particularly inopportune moment for the Bush Administration, which would like to hand over security responsibilities to those same police units as quickly as possible. That has raised the distinct and disturbing possibility that the U.S. is in fact training and arming one side in a conflict seeming to grow worse by the day. "Militias are the infrastructure of civil war," U.S. ambassador Zalmay Khalilzad told TIME recently. Khalilzad has been publicly critical of Jabr and warned that the new security ministries under the next, permanent Iraqi government should be run by competent people who have no ties to militias and who are "non-sectarian." Further U.S. support for training the police and army, he said, depends on it.
But ever since Jabr was appointed Interior Minister after the January 2005 election brought a religious Sh'ite coalition to power, Sunnis allege, he began remaking the paramilitary National Police into Shi'ite shock troops. A member of the Iranian-backed Supreme Council for the Islamic Revolution in Iraq (SCIRI), Jabr fled to Iran in the 1970s to avoid Saddam's crackdown. Jerry Burke, a former civilian senior police advisor to the Interior Ministry, said Jabr's experience with Saddam's government has left him bitter and distrustful of anyone he suspects has ties to the previous regime. That would most certainly include the former members of Saddam Hussein's Special Forces and Republican Guards which initially made up the bulk of the National Police when Jabr took charge.
The Israel Lobby
Rachel Corrie's Letters Home
Iran: The Next War
Great cartoon on Clark's ID cards
Fears of a lost generation of Afghan pupils as Taliban targets schools
Arson attacks and death threats have turned playgrounds into battlegrounds in Helmand
Declan Walsh in Sarkh Doz
Thursday March 16, 2006
Guardian
Class is out at Sarkh Doz, a sleepy village near the sweeping Helmand river. A ghostly silence fills the school playground, the gate is bolted shut and the proud yellow classrooms have been reduced to a blackened shell of cinders. Taliban arsonists set the blaze, locals say. One night a car full of militants roared up, doused the building in petrol and struck a match. Then they continued to the next village, Mangalzai, and torched that school too.
Now both buildings - recently built with American funding - are deserted, the teachers have fled and another body blow has been dealt to aid efforts in Helmand, the southern province where 3,300 British troops are deploying. "Terrible," said police chief Ahmed Samonwal, shaking his head as he walked past the blackened schools. "This is the work of our enemies." Playground has become battleground in the Afghan south, where the resurgent Taliban have launched a fierce campaign of arson, intimidation and assassination that has closed 200 schools in recent months and left 100,000 students at home.
Teachers are in the front line. In December assassins dragged a man who defied warnings to stop teaching girls from his classroom in Nad Ali, another Helmand district, and shot him at the school gate. Four other teachers have been killed and hundreds more threatened with "night letters" - handwritten notices delivered in the dark, ordering them to stop teaching or die.
The terror campaign underscores the challenge facing British troops in securing a province ruled by terror as much as central government. "Our teachers are helpless because security is so weak," said the provincial education head Hayat Allah Rafiqi. "By day the government rules but by night it is in the hands of the Taliban."
Sixty-six of Helmand's 224 schools have closed, he said, and others have scaled back classes as parents move their children to the safety of the main towns. Even there, protection is uncertain. Two days after the Nad Ali murder, gunmen burst into Karte Laghan secondary school in the provincial capital, Laskhar Gah, killing a watchman and a student. The attack occurred less than a mile from the new British base.
"We are always afraid of being shot or attacked on our way home," said Gul Ali, a female teacher of chemistry and biology at the school.
